All in All... :Pros and Cons of Home Education, Part 1

Don't your wish there were a perfect educational system? Let's see, what would it be? Public schools? Homeschools? Private Christian schools? Maybe hybrid schools? Nope, nope, nope, and nope. Each one of these options comes with some kind of cost, and each offers its own advantages.

Over the years Tim and I have watched families use every one of these methods with good fruit. We've seen other families produce bad fruit from each of these schooling options. Why's that? Because parenting trumps schooling method. If your home is in order, you can successfully use various means to educate your children, but if not, things will be more troubled no matter how you delegate teaching jobs.

This is not to say the different methods are neutral and the pros and cons even out in the end. They don't. But each family, especially each father, must determine for his particular family how the factors will play out. Knowing the pluses and minuses of educational options can help us to make choices, and perhaps even more importantly, work to minimize the disadvantages associated with our schooling plan. Since I'm most intimately familiar with homeschooling, I'd like to write a series of short posts on the upside and the downside of homeschooling. Ideally, I'll post another in this series each week.

Please note – I'm not advocating homeschooling for every family. What is best for one family is not optimal for another. Our church has decided we will not divide over educational choice, to which I heartily concur!

I'll start off with the big guns, my number one pro and con.

Pro #1: Homeschooling provides extended time and opportunities for parents to disciple their children.

More than anything else, Tim and I long for our children to love the Lord with all their hearts, souls, minds and strength. Homeschooling allows us time to intimately know our children, their sins as well as their strengths, and to be there time and again to teach, train, and disciple them.

I first saw this in action when my oldest was a kindergartener. My normally laid-back, compliant son blew up over something during school. Initially I was frustrated, thinking this wouldn't have happened, or at least I wouldn't have known about it, if he were in school. But within seconds, I realized that because his bad attitude did happen under my eye, I had the privilege of helping him see his sin, deal with it, and move on.

Because we have a large family, the extended time we have together to disciple them is all the more valuable. Sometimes this happens formally such as when my daughters and I meet for our weekly "Girl Time," but even more often as we live, learn, and work together. The ordinary business of managing a home with many children is so consuming, that were they to attend school elsewhere, I am pretty sure we would not know them so well nor have the relationships we do. We love being able to teach our children to think biblically in whatever they are studying, whether it is as we discuss historical events or wrestle with literature together. From time to time Tim has been able to take each of our sons along with him to work, helping them grow to be men. We cannot imagine how we would find time to do this well if they were away the bulk of each day.


Con #1: Homeschooling requires endurance, commitment, and just plain hard work over a long period of time, often decades. 

One of our kids once said to Tim, "Dad, homeschooling isn't expensive, is it?"

To which he replied, "No. It just costs your mother's blood."

It's true. Teaching your children at home, while incredibly rewarding, is not the easiest path. Planning, researching curriculum and methods, and then overseeing the daily instruction, not to mention keeping up with the grading and record keeping, takes large amounts of time and energy. Sometimes it can feel overwhelming. Anyone who says otherwise is not giving you the straight story. But as in everything, the Lord will give grace and strength as each day requires. Oh yeah, that's why I named my blog "As thy Days."

Deut 33: 25b "...and as thy days, so shall thy strength be."


To be continued...

When He's Down and Troubled..

O my God, my soul is in despair within me; Therefore I remember You from the land of the Jordan and the peaks of Hermon, from Mount Mizar.   (Psalm 42:5)   (Photo: Tetons)

Even before we were married, I knew Tim periodically struggled with depression. Still, I didn't really understand it. In the early years I had some kind of idea that I could fix it if I did just the right things. That didn't work out so well. But each episode would pass, and life would continue. Until the first big one. That time the depression seemed to go on endlessly. By then we had a couple of children and my life revolved around Tim and the children, making this time all the harder.

So often I wanted to ask an older woman what I should do in those times when Tim was down, seriously down. But no one else ever mentioned having a depressed husband. It was sort of embarrassing, I guess, and the church we went to at the time was good at covering over anything that might make one look less than ideal. Some of that reserve is good, as wives must always guard their words about their husbands. Yet, I still wish there had been someone to talk with.

My husband isn't the only man who deals with periodic melancholy, as the Puritans aptly put it. So recently Tim asked me to write what I've learned these past thirty-five years or so about loving a husband who sinks into the blues from time to time. (And of course, depression doesn't limit itself to men. But here I want to address it from a wife's perspective.)

1. Pray
I'm quite fond of the Carole King/James Taylor song from which I took the title of this piece ("You've Got a Friend".) Yet even though I can be a friend and encouragement to my husband when he struggles, I can't solve all his problems just by being there. But there is one who sticks closer than a brother. So I go to the Father and pray for my beloved. 

Here are a few scripture passages I sometimes pray through:
Romans 15: 13 Now may the God of hope fill you with all joy and peace in believing, so that you will abound in hope by the power of the Holy Spirit.
Psalm 42 - all!
Psalm 130 - all! 
Lamentations 3 - all

Keep a notebook with scripture prayers to make it easy to find the ones you want to use.


2. Read John Piper's When the Darkness Will Not Lift.
I wrote about this little book about a year ago. You can download a free copy from the Desiring God website or buy a Kindle version. Nothing I've read compares with the helpfulness of this book. And at a mere 73 pages, it doesn't take long to read.

3. Remind him of truths about God.
With depression, one tends to view God with a warped mind. We don't view God accurately, and we tell lies to ourself about His goodness and mercy. Sure He loves others, just not me. One of the most useful things we can do to encourage a loved one dealing with depression is to remind them of the truth about God and His character.

Richard Baxter wrote a wonderful sermon on "The Cure of Melancholy and Overmuch Sorrow."
In a section called "Duties of Friends and Relatives of the Depressed," he includes this: "Often set before them the great truths of the gospel which are fittest to comfort them; and read them informing, comforting books; and live in a loving, cheerful manner with them."


3. Try to not fall yourself!
This is a tough one! Nothing is more natural than to respond in sympathy for your beloved by also becoming discouraged and losing hope. When his world isn't going right, neither is yours. But I can tell you that almost nothing is more counterproductive than this. Do anything you can to avoid falling into the pit with him. As Piper puts it, fight for joy yourself.

 Ecc. 4: 9, 10 Two are better than one because they have a good return for their labor. For if either of them falls, the one will lift up his companion. But woe to the one who falls when there is not another to lift him up.

4. Express your respect for and confidence in him
Don't let him debate with you on these things either. If he says, "But you don't understand. Really..." Just respond with a smile, "Well, that's how I see things." Your love and belief in him will do more than you can imagine at any time, but especially when he feels low.


5. Don't give in to your own fears.
Trust God to do His good work in and through your husband. Be patient.


6. Don't try to analyze him.
This one is especially for me. I have an analytical brain, and am forever trying to figure things out and solve problems. But my husband needs me to be his wife, not his shrink or MD. When I tell him what I think is going on or give my "helpful" prescriptions, they are usually less than helpful.

7. Don't let him isolate himself, even if he wants to. 
Invite good friends over for dinner. Not someone who will be draining and need lots of good counsel, but someone you can laugh and relax with. Plan some fun times out together whether it is a hike at a nearby nature preserve or a walk around your neighborhood. Go out for dinner together. Find fun, low-key things to do out of the house.



8. Find a friend you can talk and pray with.
Yes, you need to be careful what you say. You don't need to share specifics, but having a friend to pray with regularly is a great help in all times, including those times when your lover is in the depths.

Gal 6:2 Bear one another's burdens, and thereby fulfill the law of Christ.


9. Encourage him to seek help if it seems extra-long or extra-serious.
Also, don't pooh-pooh medical sources of depression. I'd always read about these possible causes, but thought they were improbable. Last year for me was the most difficult emotionally I can remember. We had legitimate reasons to be discouraged, and both Tim and I were. But my response to life's situations was out of proportion. A normally fairly unemotionaly woman, I was crying daily. And worse, many days I felt no reason to go on. And then, during a routine doctor visit, I learned my thyroid was barely functioning. As I wrote a few months ago, once I got on thyoid replacement medication, my depression almost immediately lifted. Praise God for this simple help. So now, I no longer despise the idea of medical roots of depression. It can definitely be worth checking out.


10. Make love. Often! It helps.
Definitely more fun than Prozac, and maybe more effective.




God can use depression in our lives, as He can use all suffering, to draw us to Himself. Trust Him for His work in your husband and in yourself.


II Cor. 4:  7-10 
But we have this treasure in earthen vessels, so that the surpassing greatness of the power will be of God and not from ourselves;
 8 ¶ we are afflicted in every way, but not crushed; perplexed, but not despairing; 9 persecuted, but not forsaken; struck down, but not destroyed; 10 always carrying about in the body the dying of Jesus, so that the life of Jesus also may be manifested in our body.

It's Got to Go!


You've heard the old saw about nature abhorring a vacuum? It sure has held true in our house. When we moved to this house, double the size of our previous one, at first we had a couple entire empty rooms, but the inevitable happened and those vacuums soon became filled with more and more stuff, not to mention more children!



During the school year, it's all we can do to keep up with the routine homekeeping, with an occasional stab at dejunking. So each summer I try to get serious about thinning our belongings and ordering those that are allowed to remain. This week I'm working on our basement storage area.


My frugal nature makes me tend to want to hold on to things, thinking, "But it might come in handy some day!" And truth be told, "it" often does, which only feeds my desire to hoard stuff. This is not healthy in any sense, and I do love the order that is only possible when there is not an overabundance of junk.

For any natural de-clutterers reading this, you must be rolling your eyes at me. And I deserve it. But for any other packrats like me, here are the principles I've found helpful:

1. Touch (and open) everything. To really get rid of things, you have to take everything off the shelves, out of boxes, and touch it. It's not enough to simply rearrange boxes. For example, if I look at a bookshelf I want to thin, I can either scan the titles and pull out a few to cull, or I can remove all the books and sort them, deciding which merit staying on the shelves. This alone has made a huge difference.

2. I find myself asking, "Now just why am I keeping this anyway?" Often I don't have a good answer, so out it goes.

3. For the things I do decide to keep, I ask, "How can I make this accessible?" I want to not just store these things, but put them to use.

4. "Like with like." OK, I know this is obvious! But over time, I get slipshod and squeeze things into a convenient place instead of rearranging so the similar items can be stored together. I was thrilled to get all my food preservation equipment into the same zone so I can see what I have and find it readily.

5. Label shelves, not just boxes. A label maker would be ideal, but I've been using masking tape on the shelves to show what belongs there. When I reorganize closets or cabinets, I make index cards showing what belongs on each shelf, and then I affix the card to the inside door. This helps especially when you have children putting things away.

6. Some things are much harder to let go than others. Particularly, thinning kids' portfolios is difficult  for me. Tim says this is because that work represents my blood. So I save parts and dump the rest. I think I've liberated enough binders and sheet protectors to last a lifetime.

7. If I can't finish an area in the time I've allotted for it (usually one week of dejunking), I leave behind a list of places to start the next time I cycle back.

8. The new rule is: No more compulsive saving! If something new comes in, something has to go out. Everything from fabric to camping gear has its own zone, and if something doesn't fit, it is time to toss!

OK - that's it. I know it's kind of a "no duh" list. But keeping these things foremost as I de-clutter is making a big difference on this go-round, and I figured maybe there is someone out there as prone to collecting stuff that "might be useful someday" as I am. Now - for the family room side of the basement!

Co-op Book Club!




With all the co-ops we've been in, I don't know why we'd never done this before. Co-op book club! What could be a more natural fit for homeschoolers?

For the past two years my youngest boys and I have had the delight of joining several times a month with good friends and their children for supplemental school activities. Before we started, the moms got together to see what types of subjects would lend themselves to our joint sessions. Since we are all in different eras of history and tackle our studies in somewhat different forms, we wondered what would work well communally. We hit on a formula with a bit of science, some art, opportunities for public speaking, and a monthly book club.

Recently we held our last co-op for this school year, and we asked each child to tell about something he or she particularly enjoyed. More than anything else, the stories the children related had to do with books read and the book club activities. Personally I loved book club weeks as well. It was so much fun to see the children's enthusiasm as they discussed among themselves, whether they loved a book or thought it overrated. Talking about a book with ten of your friends is just not the same as discussing it with your mom alone.

Since book club fell under another mom's jurisdiction, these ideas are not mine, but rather Heather U's. With her permission, I'd like to share them here with the hope that they might inspire some others of you to try your own homeschool book club. The younger children's book club consisted of books and activities from Five in a Row. The older children (2nd-6th grades) first discussed their books, delving into some literary analysis as they considered protagonists, antagonists, settings, and what point the author was trying to make. After talking together, we moved into some activities based on that month's selection. Here's a bit of what went on.


September: Homer Price (Robert McCloskey)

Each family chose one chapter to dramatize. Among others, options included "The Doughnuts", "The Case of the Cosmic Comic," and "Mystery Yarn."











October: Survival Books - Your choice!

This one was different because the children were assigned a theme instead of a particular book. A couple of the kids read The Iceberg Hermit by Arthur Roth, which tells the somewhat true story of a young man shipwrecked in 1757 on an Arctic iceberg. Fascinating!
For our co-op book club, the students talked about the various books they had read, found common elements, and described what their protagonist faced and how he survived. We had the kids come up with a list of items they would want to have if they faced a survival situation, then we put these on strips of paper and drew a few out of a hat. Using those items only, we had the kids work in two groups to come up with their own survival story. Finally, the children tried making fire starters from accordion-folded newspapers dipped in wax and we played around with magnesium fire starters.  








November: An Old Fashioned Thanksgiving (Louisa May Alcott)    

Our family enjoys this story every Thanksgiving, but we learned some new things about this old favorite with this month's book club. Revolving around games and food, this book club was a favorite for many.
After the feast in the tale, the Bassett family turns to game-playing and dancing:
"Blind-man's bluff," "Hunt the slipper," "Come, Philander," and other lively games soon set everyone bubbling over with jollity, and when Eph struck up "Money Musk" on his fiddle, old and young fell into their places for a dance. All down the long kitchen they stood, Mr. and Mrs. Bassett at the top, the twins at the bottom, and then away they went, heeling and toeing, cutting pigeon-wings, and taking their steps in a way that would convulse modern children with their new-fangled romps called dancing. Mose and Tilly covered themselves with glory by the vigor with which they kept it up, till fat Aunt Cinthy fell into a chair, breathlessly declaring that a very little of such exercise was enough for a woman of her "heft."
The boys who make up the bulk of our crowd wouldn't have appreciated dancing, but they sure did enjoy playing the games. And then they finished the afternoon by tucking into some old-fashioned delectables such as Indian pudding and cranberry bread.  Yum!







December: The Best Christmas Pageant Ever (Barbara Robinson)  


Because several of the families were dealing with illnesses, we held a simplified book club in December at one family's home. We ate popcorn and watched a video version of this holiday tale and then discussed lessons from this book. Very enjoyable!





January: Snow Treasure (Marie McSwigan)
A favorite of mine since childhood, Snow Treasure tells the amazing story of Norwegian children who sneak $9,000,000 in gold past the eyes of the Nazis who have taken over the village. Will the children prevail using sleds and ingenuity? This is a wonderful tale of courage.

After discussing what is and what isn't known about this event, and if it really happened or not, we got busy making diaramas. Each child brought a shoebox and created his own interpretation of a key scene from the book.




February: Peter Pan (J. M. Barrie)

Oh, Peter! The boy who doesn't want to grow up! How interesting to hear the discussion on this book and see the different takes on the story depending on the age of the reader. For younger ones, it was merely a fun adventure story, but the older ones understood, though didn't approve of, the theme of not wanting to grow up.

For the activity this week, the children were given the assignment of creating their own game using elements from the story. They decided to make the game revolve around the flight to Neverland. Some players were clouds, others birds, others Peter, Wendy, John, and Michael. Peter and the children had to take food (balls) from the birds while the clouds tried to make them drop the food by bumping them. If Peter's team were able to gather all of the food, they would win. If the clouds bumped a single player three times, he was out. If all the players were knocked out, the birds and clouds won. As you can tell, it was a bit complicated, but great fun! This is the activity mentioned as a favorite by more children than any other.






March: Spring Break!

April: The Enchanted Castle (Edith Nesbit) 

The Enchanted Castle is another of E. Nesbit's hilarious fantasy tales. It involves four children, a magic ring, and of course, an enchanted castle. But being a Nesbit story, nothing goes off as you might expect, leading to surprises and laughs.

During the book, the children perform a play, but knowing they would lack enough of an audience, they create some Ugly-Wuglies from old clothes, masks and broomsticks. And then, the Ugly-Wuglies come to life. Mwha ha ha ha!

We asked the children to bring supplies for making their own Ugly-Wuglies. Most worked together in pairs to create their characters. Ben reassembled his fellow at home where he remained without getting up to any of the exciting deeds of his namesake.
































May: The Bears of Blue River (Charles Major)

For our final selection, the children read this wonderful Indiana story. Balser, a young lad, loves hunting, especially for bears. He and his friends end up in all kinds of improbable situations, usually involving a bear or two.

Surprisingly, at our co-op discussion we learned that some of the more outlandish episodes in the book were actually based on very true events! There was indeed a natural gas explosion like the one described in the book.

The children tried to locate the site of the story based on descriptions in the book and using a number of old and newer maps. (Check out this document for maps.) Then we went to the gym so the kids could try out some of the games mentioned in the book. Once again games were a big hit, especially "Wolf."






So that's a taste of our book club for this year. Like I said, the concept works well for a number of families, whether you have two or a larger crowd. I'm looking forward to seeing what will happen with it next year!

One Less UFO



UFO: UnFinished Object in quilting parlance

This one was a long time in the making. Or more accurately, a long time sitting in a box waiting to be found and finished. Originally it was to be for my oldest son's high school graduation. With time to in short supply, I gave myself plenty of it, starting when Andrew was a sophomore, working in bits and pieces. While Kara and I waited to hear election results in 2000, we stayed up late working together. She pressed while I sewed. And then it went in the box. About five weeks later, a few days after the Supreme Court finally ruled that George W. Bush had in fact won the election, our eighth baby was born, dooming the quilt blocks to stayed untouched. Two years later as Andrew started his first year at Purdue, baby #9 put in his appearance. Somehow that quilt never made it out of its box.

Fast forward to this year. Hmmm. Andrew was approaching another graduation.When I pulled out the box from under my bed, I found that it was closer to finished than I'd remembered, and it went together without too much further hassle. But if I had to hand quilt the top, my preferred finish, it might sit another decade. So I found a lovely couple who do long-arm machine quilting at very reasonable prices.  (Sheila's Sew Time.) A month later, I had it back and ready for binding. Hurrah! One less UFO under my bed!

All-over quilt design with cotton batting






Done!

Just in case you have any squabblers

etc.usf.edu





It is honorable for a man to stop striving, since any fool can start a quarrel.   Proverbs 20:3 (NKJV)


A man's discretion makes him slow to anger, And it is his glory to overlook a transgression. (NAS95) Proverbs 19:11

Don't you just love how practical God's Word is?

In Case of Failure (First posted Feb, 2006)


It was the eve of D-Day when the Allied troops would fly and sail across the channel to invade at a location the Germans were least expecting: Normandy, France. For two years generals had been planning, and now 2,000,000 soldiers were massed in southern England, poised for just the right moment to enter France and begin to push back the Germans. The weather was foul, but because of the moon and tides, this would be the best shot for at least a month. Still, General Eisenhower, Supreme Commander of the Allied troops did not know if the invasion would be a success or a horrific failure. And so he scrawled out this note as a press release to be used “in case of failure.”

Eisenhower's "failure" note, found weeks later by his aides


Our landings in the Cherbourg-Havre area have failed to gain a satisfactory foothold and I have withdrawn the troops. My decision to attack at this time and place was based upon the best information available. The troops, air and navy did all that bravery and devotion to duty could do. If any blame or fault attaches to the attempt, it is mine alone.  













Thankfully Gen. Eisenhower did not need to issue this as the invasion was a brilliant, though costly, success.

I’ve just finished reading The Longest Day, by Cornelius Ryan, a book which kept me up late at nights, spellbound by the bravery of the men who fought in WW II. No, war books are not normally an interest for me at all, but I wanted to bone up on this era of history before teaching it in a few weeks. I highly recommend this 50 year old book which was based on hundreds of interviews with American, British, Canadian, French and German survivors of that momentous day which marked the beginning of the end of the war.


So many things impressed me in this book. It tells of the 18,000 men who parachuted into France, often landing miles off target or in flooded swamplands or even on church steeples, of the glider trains (planes), of the thousands who landed on the beaches loaded with mines and other booby traps, knowing that death was a very likely outcome, and of the men and women of the French underground. What has happened to men and women since then? Surely they were of stouter fabric than we are today. One of the reasons we study history and teach it to our children is to be inspired to bravery by the actions of our forefathers.

Eisenhower’s words, too, impacted me. In the actual press release that went out, telling of the mission’s achievements, he did not take credit, though if it had failed he was prepared to take the personal blame. According to Doug Wilson, in Future Men, this is a mark of a true man: he is willing to accept responsibility when things go wrong without making excuses. As parents it is essential that we teach out children, boys and girls as well,  to own the responsibility for their actions. We must not let them give us excuses for what they should have done. And even worse, we must not make excuses for them.

Blame-shifting goes back to Eden when Adam blamed “the woman whom You gave to be with me” and Eve blamed the serpent. I see it in myself regularly. Something goes wrong, and too often my response is not to take personal responsibility but to look around and see if there is someone else handy. My children do it too. Here’s a nearly trivial example, but the kind that happens all the time. Last night we were going through the bedtime routine. I asked Paul, 5, who normally takes care of this himself, if he had brushed his teeth, and he responded that he had not.

“Why not?” I asked.

“Because you didn’t help me!” (Now, note that he does this himself 95% of the time, and he had not asked for help. Instead he had been playing.) But by saying that, suddenly it was not his fault but mine that his teeth were unbrushed. Well, this of course, provided an excellent opportunity to explain to Paul, while I brushed his teeth, why making excuses is unacceptable, and that the correct answer to my query would have been, “I have no excuse, Mom.”

I’m looking forward to our study of World War II in a few weeks. My boys especially will profit by looking at the actions of courage by men who were willing to risk their lives, men who were willing to live and die with honor. They will remember their Great- Uncle Rubert, who was killed in France not long after D-Day. And as we study D-Day, I will read to them General Eisenhower’s words that he did not ever need to send.

“Boys must learnt to say, regularly – to God, to others, and to themselves – that they were wrong when they were wrong, and that they were responsible when they were responsible. When they do this, they will discover that authority naturally flows to those who take responsibility. That same authority naturally flees from those who seek to shift the responsibility or the blame. When boys learn to do this, they are learning what it means to be a young man. When young men do this, they are learning what it means to be a grown man.” - Future Men

Feb. 2006


Update: Having just read The Longest Day again, this time to my youngest sons, now ages 9 and 12, I still give this book a hearty recommendation. However, as an adult war book, it contains earthy language and sometimes graphic descriptions. Reading aloud allows a parent to edit on the fly as appropriate for the age of the listeners.

This time through I was again impressed with Einsenhower's readiness to assume responsibility if the invasion failed. How stark a contrast to today's political leaders who seem only too quick to find someone else to blame! Teaching our children to own up to their wrongs as we arbitrate disputes or deal with disobedience is a good place to start in training men of honor.   (May 21,2013)

Purdue Commemencement 2013


So far we've been able to score two-for-one on our Purdue graduations!


2007

Back in 2007 Andrew and Kara completed their undergrad degrees together. (Kara saved some money by squashing her classes into three years.)







2013 Kristen and Andrew with John Purdue himself.
(Kristen earned some snazzy tassels, too, but hadn't received them by the photo shoot.)





Deciding that it was such a good thing to have an older brother watch out for his younger sister, we made Andrew stay at Purdue for another six years so he could be there for his next sister's Purdue tenure.













No, not really. As an undergrad Andrew found a wonderful professor to work with in the electrical engineering department, and stayed on for his PhD as he dove into research in radar that both sends and receives. He works for the military. There. That pretty much exhausts my knowledge of his research. (But - tada! I will possibly be more enlightened after reading his thesis, which I will do this summer!)










We had a lovely weekend in West Lafayette! Besides attending the two commencements plus Kristen's nursing pinning ceremony, we also had a wonderful time celebrating with Andrew and Kara's church and lab friends at a cookout at Andrew's house.








And here's our family (minus Kara and crew) on a pillar of one of Purdue's beautiful fountains. From the top: Ben, Paul, Tim, Peter, Kristen, Andrew, Jonathan, Faith, Amanda, and me.